The government has announced plans to abolish police and crime commissioners (PCCs) in a significant overhaul of the policing system. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood criticized the PCC system, labeling it a “failed experiment” and proposed transferring accountability of local police forces to mayors.
PCCs, introduced in 2012 by former Home Secretary Theresa May, are elected officials responsible for setting police force budgets and appointing chief constables. Home Office minister Sarah Jones stated that the PCC model has undermined local police accountability and negatively impacted chief constable recruitment.
In a parliamentary address, Jones revealed the decision to abolish PCCs by 2028 and transition their functions to mayors where possible. New policing and crime boards will be established to oversee police forces in areas without mayor-led policing plans.
The move aims to enhance community safety, support local businesses, and promote vibrant town centers by empowering local leaders with policing responsibilities. Jones clarified that the decision was not a reflection on the PCC model itself or the PCCs currently in office.
The Labour party has long advocated for the removal of PCCs to allocate savings to frontline policing. The Home Office estimates that scrapping PCCs will save at least £100 million and contribute to funding additional frontline officers.
However, Emily Spurrell, chairwoman of the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners and PCC for Merseyside, expressed concerns over the decision, highlighting the risk of creating an accountability void. She emphasized the positive impact of PCCs in enhancing policing transparency and community engagement.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood pledged to implement reforms ensuring police accountability to local mayors or councils. The cost savings from abolishing PCCs will be redirected to increase neighborhood policing presence nationwide, combating crime and safeguarding communities.
Mahmood acknowledged the contributions of current and former PCCs, recognizing their dedication to serving communities until the end of their terms.